Unsafe Device Removal: The Results

Posted: 2017-04-14 | "It's Complicated"

Following my proposed experiment in data destruction, a few kind readers tried it out and let me know what happened1. I’ve summarised the results below, to try and see if there’s any common pattern.

Software Format Was recovery possible?
Apple Preview JPEG No (rendered image still shown and could be captured via screenshot)2
GIMP JPEG Yes (with minor alterations to the data, likely within allowed limits for JPEG)2
Imagemagick display JPEG Yes (result not binary-identical)3
Ubuntu Image Viewer JPEG No4
Ubuntu Document Viewer PDF Yes4
PDF reader PDF PDF from a browser, stay in a PDF reader after the browser closes but can’t be saved5
Word (Windows 95) DOC (on a floppy!) No (but re-inserting the floppy worked!)6

As far as I can tell from this data, there isn’t much of a pattern here. Broadly, the observed behaviour seems to depend on the software rather than the format, and ‘viewer’ style applications appear less likely to allow re-saving than ‘editor’ apps (but the behaviour of the Ubuntu Document Viewer shows this is not a robust finding). All we can be sure of at this point is this: “It’s complicated”.

To find out what’s going on, we’ll need to look more closely at what happens when we open a file…

  1. Thanks also to Nick Krabbenhöft for pointing out that I could have been a bit more careful about my original experiment, and that would have helped work out where the JPEG differences came from in the case of re-saving the image from GIMP. That said, I expect such minor differences are down to small variations in the implementation of the JPEG decompression scheme, as permitted by the standard. i.e. my final image is likely the no more different that the same original image might be when rendered by a different software application

  2. See the original post  2

  3. Result from @atomotic 

  4. Result from @archivalistic  2

  5. From @andrewjbtw 

  6. Also from @andrewjbtw 

Next in series: Access starts with 'Lo... » « Previous in series: Unsafe Device Removal

Digital Preservation  Keeping Codes  Lessons Learned

Posted: 2017-04-14 | anj


Fighting entropy since 1993

© Dr Andrew N. Jackson — CC-BY